Spreadsheets vs a UGC creator CRM
Almost every UGC creator starts in a spreadsheet, and that is the correct place to start. It's free, it's instant, and for your first handful of deals it does the job better than any app because there's nothing to learn.
The question isn't whether spreadsheets are bad. It's the point at which maintaining one costs more than it saves — and that point arrives quietly, usually around the time you stop being able to answer "who owes me money?" without opening three tabs.
What a spreadsheet genuinely does better
Total flexibility and zero cost. You can restructure it in thirty seconds, it works exactly how you think, and nobody can change it under you. If your process is unusual, a spreadsheet bends to it in a way no product will. Anyone telling you spreadsheets are simply wrong is selling something.
Where the two actually differ
| With a spreadsheet or Notion template | With sproutUGC | |
|---|---|---|
| Following up | You remember, or you don't. A stale row looks the same as a fresh one. | Deals quiet for 14+ days surface on your dashboard as pitches going cold. |
| Invoicing | Rebuild the document each time, track numbers by hand, hope the format looks professional. | Generated from the closed deal with a sequential number, your branding, and a payment link. |
| Usage rights | A free-text cell you'll never re-read, so licences expire unnoticed. | Recorded against the deal with an alert before the window lapses — which is renewal revenue. |
| What you show brands | A Drive folder, a Linktree, and a PDF rate card that's three versions out of date. | A public portfolio and a live media-kit link that update everywhere the moment you change them. |
| Knowing what you earned | Revenue is visible; profit per deal is a weekend project. | P&L builds itself from paid invoices and logged expenses, with profit per deal and per brand. |
| When it breaks | One bad paste, and there's no history to recover from. | Structured records with defined relationships — a deal can't quietly lose its invoice. |
Stay where you are if…
- You've done fewer than about five deals and you're still working out your own process.
- Your workflow is genuinely unusual and you value bending the tool over any built-in structure.
- You only ever work with one or two retainer clients and nothing is ever in flight.
Time to move if…
- You've lost track of whether a brand replied, or missed a follow-up you meant to send.
- You can't answer "what's outstanding right now?" in under a minute.
- You've licensed content and can't say when the term ends.
- You're spending more time maintaining the sheet than working the pipeline.
- You want a portfolio brands can find rather than one you have to send.
Questions
Can I import my existing spreadsheet?
Yes. Brands and contacts import from CSV or Excel, so you don't retype anything. Expenses import from CSV too.
Is a Notion template enough?
For tracking, often yes — a good template gives you structure a blank sheet doesn't. What it can't do is generate branded invoices with payment links, host a public portfolio, alert you before a licence expires, or build your P&L. Those need an application, not a document.
What does it cost to move?
The free plan is genuinely free and doesn't expire, so you can run both in parallel for a month before deciding. Import your contacts, publish a portfolio, and see whether you go back.
Run both for a month
The free plan doesn't expire and imports your existing contacts from CSV. Keep whichever one you actually open.
Start free